Investing in manager development is widely recognised as one of the most impactful ways to improve team performance, engagement, and retention. Yet when it comes to measuring and proving the return on investment (ROI) of these programmes, many HR and L&D leaders find themselves in murky waters.

It’s not that manager development doesn’t deliver results - it absolutely does. The challenge lies in quantifying its impact in a way that resonates with key stakeholders and secures continued buy-in for future initiatives.

So, why is proving ROI for manager development so challenging, and how can you overcome these hurdles?

The Unique Challenges of Proving ROI in Manager Development

1. The "Soft Skills" Problem

Management development often focuses on areas like communication, emotional intelligence, and team motivation. While these skills are undeniably critical to success, they are harder to measure compared to more tangible outputs like sales or production metrics.

For example, how do you quantify the impact of improved communication between a manager and their team? Or the benefits of a manager who fosters higher engagement and collaboration? The link to business outcomes is there - but it’s indirect and requires a nuanced approach to measurement.

2. Time Lags Between Training and Results

Unlike technical training that can yield immediate results, the impact of management development often unfolds over time. A manager who completes a development programme might not immediately transform team performance, but over months, their improved leadership can reduce turnover, boost engagement, and improve productivity.

This time lag from some training interventions makes it harder to draw a direct line between the investment in training and the results it generates, especially when stakeholders expect quick, visible wins.

3. Attributing Impact to Development Initiatives

Managers operate in complex environments where multiple factors influence outcomes. Was a recent increase in team performance due to the manager’s new skills, a change in team dynamics, or an unrelated organisational initiative?

Attribution becomes even murkier when multiple programmes or initiatives are running simultaneously. Without clear data, it’s easy for the impact of management development to be underestimated - or even overlooked entirely.

4. Lack of Baseline Data

To measure improvement, you need a starting point - but many organisations fail to collect robust baseline data before launching management development programmes. Without a clear picture of where managers and their teams were before the training, it’s difficult to demonstrate how far they’ve come.

5. Misaligned Expectations

Stakeholders often expect management development programmes to deliver hard ROI figures, like revenue growth or cost savings, even when the real benefits are more qualitative. This mismatch in expectations can create pressure to "prove" ROI in ways that don’t fully capture the value of the programme.

How to Overcome These Challenges

Proving the ROI of management development isn’t impossible - it just requires a clear, structured approach. By identifying measurable outcomes, aligning expectations with stakeholders, and using the right tools to track progress, you can demonstrate the true value of your investment in management development.

Questions to Consider

If you’re struggling to prove ROI for your management development programmes, here are a few questions to guide your thinking:

• What measurable outcomes can you track that align with your organisation’s goals? Examples might include employee retention, engagement scores, or productivity metrics.
• Do you have baseline data to compare against? If not, how can you start collecting it for future programmes?
• Are you tracking behavioural changes as well as business results? The two are often linked, but both need to be monitored to tell a complete story.
• Are your stakeholders aligned on what success looks like? Clarify what metrics matter most to them and tailor your ROI narrative accordingly.

Ready to Prove the ROI of Your L&D Programmes?

Proving the value of management development doesn’t have to be an uphill battle. With the right framework, you can connect the dots between your L&D initiatives and the results that matter most to your organisation.

Download our free guide, "Proving the ROI of Your L&D Programmes in 5 Steps," to learn how to:

• Set clear objectives and metrics for success.
• Capture the right data to track progress.
• Align stakeholders on what ROI means for your organisation.

Download the guide here

Your L&D programmes deserve the recognition they’ve earned - this guide will show you how to make it happen.

‍